You'll hear this refrain again and again this semester. Which side are you on?
The point of this blog project, as I've emphasized in class, is to help you figure out where you stand on issues concerning Appalachia and Appalachia's relationship to the rest of the world. As we read in our text, being on the fence about the issue of slavery is partly to blame for the disconnect between this region and other parts of the country. Indifference to issues that seem not to concern us in Appalachia is part of our cultural heritage. But it isolates us and keeps us in the dark about issues that actually DO concern us. Things that happen "out there" are not disconnected from us. Appalachia is, and always has been, intricately interconnected with the rest of the world.
So... question everything. If you don't know which side you're on, it might be because you haven't thought about it much yet. Think about it now. Explore here. Take whatever positions you already hold and open up a dialogue with others who may just teach you about something you didn't know, who might enlighten you on some aspect of an issue you haven't yet considered, who might in the end change your opinion. It's okay to change your mind about issues, to adjust your thinking. This is called learning. And the best way to learn about a subject is to immerse yourself in it, to ask questions, to take positions and argue for them, to change your mind until you can hold firm on the issues that matter most to you because you have investigated and become better informed, you've tested your opinions by discoursing with others, and you have come away with a deeply held opinion. Not a superficial opinion, not one handed down to you by your ancestors or forced onto you by your employers or teachers or friends. But a deeply held opinion that you have earned for yourself. An opinion that just might change the world (or one small but important part of it) someday.
I watched a CNN Soledad O'Brien documentary recently about the new battle for Blair Mountain in southern West Virginia, and something about it reminded me of Alice Walker's story "Everyday Use." Not everyone knows the significance of Blair Mountain. To a handful of historians, it's an important landmark, the site of the biggest labor uprising in American history when coal miners (some accounts say as many as 10,000) marched against the coal industry that was denying them the right to unionize. It's one of the most fascinating, though little-known, chapters in our nation's history. That's the old battle.
To environmentalists, Blair Mountain is just that, a mountain in need of being saved from the ravages of mountaintop removal mining practices. This is the new battle.
Soledad O'Brien makes the best attempt I've seen to cover the story objectively.
Other documentaries on the subject are clearly either anti-mountaintop removal or pro-coal. Since I read Ann Pancake's eye-opening novel Strange as This Weather Has Been a few years ago, I -- like many others -- have come to view mountaintop removal as one of our generation's great evils. Commercials advertising "clean coal" infuriate me. Watch the documentary Black Diamonds or Coal Country and see which side you're on. It's becoming easier and easier to recognize big industry as the enemy, and I'm glad that advocates fighting to save our mountains have finally grabbed the attention of the big news channels (a miracle when you consider who's paying the bills) not to mention the EPA. For many of us, Soledad O'Brien as well as the rest of us looking on in horror at what's been taking place right under our noses, the EPA's ruling to deny MTR permits on Blair Mountain is a victory.
But something from this film struck me that I hadn't considered before.
No one wants to paint an ugly picture of the coal miners fighting to save their jobs. If those mountains aren't mined, one way or another, miners go without work and pay. And if the history of Blair Mountain means anything to us, miners have earned our nation's respect. It's easy to villianize the coal industry itself, the evil land owners and operators who have oppressed West Virginians for decades and kept the area mired in poverty. That's an easy mark. They're greedy overlords, no question. And filmmakers are sensitive about how they portray the miners and their families who are reliant upon the coal industry. With a few poor exceptions, Soledad O'Brien's piece seems especially careful not to depict workers as stereotypes, a commendable effort. Still, there's just a hint of arrogance in their attitudes. Anti-MTR advocates view those coal miners and their families sympathetically. They see them as victims, noble savages (though I doubt they'd characterize it this way as it's far too politically incorrect) who are being exploited by BIG Coal. When I say "they," I mean "we." We view them that way, myself included. "What you poor naive workers don't understand," we try to tell them, "is that your job is the problem. That's BIG Coal's ace in the pocket. As long as they keep you fighting for that job, you'll look the other way while they take everything that ever belonged to you. This is YOUR mountain," we try to say. Why don't they hear us?
Here's what makes me think of Alice Walker's story. The small army shown marching toward Blair Mountain in Soledad O'Brien's piece is made up, by and large, of outsiders. Students and sympathizers from beyond the region, people who call AppalaCHia AppalaSHia, who speak lovingly of West Virginia's "beautiful, wonderul biodiversity." Or else those returning to the area after being transformed by the wider world, coming home to lay claim on the "history" of Blair Mountain.
Treehuggers, the locals call them. "Go home, tree hugger!" they holler as the marchers pass by. "They're trying to shut us down. They don't even live here," one woman says. "My pawpaw was in the first march!" another woman shouts from the other side of the highway. "You have no right to be here!" "I feel it's a point they want to argue, to preserve the mountain because the battle was fought on it," a local mountaintop removal miner says. "I would hate to see it go. But if meant three or four hundred men losing their jobs, flatten it out."
Such a peculiar response from those most affected.
I'm given new pause. I see more shades of gray. Is a quilt (or a mountain) something to be hung reverently on a wall? Or is it something of everday use? And to whom does it belong? To those who will inherit it tomorrow, or to those who will use it today?